Dynamite plots in R

For some time I’ve contemplated creating a function for creating the dynamite plots beloved by many of the applied sciences. There’s a lot of criticism regarding their utility, and there are several ways that present data in a more intelligible way. A search on the subject brings up pages with such emotive titles as “Dynamite plots: unmitigated evil?” and “Why dynamite plots are BAD”. The “Beware of Dynamite” poster sums up the main problem with dynamite plots by concluding “Intentionally or not, a dynamite plot hides more than it reveals”.

All that said, I’m an R advocate. If being able to to create dynamite plots is going to encourage people to use R, I can cope with their inadequacies. Here’s hoping that the paucity of information required to create them makes people reconsider.

dynamitePlot < - function(height, error, names = NA,
        significance = NA, ylim = c(0,maxLim), …){
    maxLim < - 1.1* max(mapply(sum, height, error))
    bp < - barplot(height, names.arg = names, ylim = ylim, ...)
    arrows(x0 = bp, y0 = height, y1 = height + error, angle = 90)
    text(x = bp, y = 0.2 + height + error, labels = significance)
}

Values < - c(1,2,5,4)
Errors < - c(0.25, 0.5, 0.33, 0.12)
Names < - paste("Trial", 1:4)
Sig < - c("a", "a", "b", "b")

dynamitePlot(Values, Errors, names = Names, significance = Sig)

The result looks like this: The code is also available on gitHub.